Smileys Ice Cream – Authentic Erie Ice Cream Shop with Classic Flavors

Overview

Nestled on Water Street in Erie, Pennsylvania, Smiley's Ice Cream is a delightful spot for those seeking a refreshing treat. This local ice cream shop has built a reputation for serving rich, creamy ice cream that captures both classic and inventive flavors. Its location at 1924 Water St situates it perfectly for a casual stop amidst the city’s lively atmosphere.

At Smiley's Ice Cream, the emphasis is on quality and variety. Whether you crave a timeless vanilla scoop or something more adventurous, the selection caters to families, friends, and individuals looking for a sweet escape. The shop's warm and inviting space encourages guests to unwind and savor their dessert, making it an ideal place for casual outings or spontaneous indulgences.

Known for its friendly service and cheerful ambiance, Smiley's creates an experience that goes beyond just ice cream. The community-focused environment ensures it appeals to a broad audience, from children enjoying after-school treats to adults craving a nostalgic taste. Its phone number, +1 814-737-9973, is handy for inquiries or special orders, adding a layer of convenience for customers.

In essence, Smiley's Ice Cream stands out as a go-to destination in Erie for anyone looking to enjoy quality frozen desserts in a welcoming setting. Its commitment to taste and comfort makes each visit a memorable one, inviting all to share in the simple joy of a well-made scoop.

What Customers Say

Heather Vickery

Mar 7,2026

5/5

We had the pleasure of working with Smiley's Ice Cream Truck for a wedding WE coordinated, and it was such a fun and memorable addition to the day! The ice cream was delicious—fresh, flavorful, and a huge hit with guests. The staff was equally wonderful—friendly, professional, and easy to work with from start to finish. They helped make the experience smooth and enjoyable. We would absolutely recommend them for any event looking to add a sweet and interactive treat! WE actually get the pleasure to work with them a few other time this season! — Heather, WE Weddings & Events

Amidabel Valentin

Mar 7,2026

5/5

I would like to say that The Ice Creams are Amazing and the taste is Wonderful , and also my family and I Would Like To Thanks the owner and the staff members For Allowing My Niece to take this lovely picture. and for being so Nice

A.J MIC

Mar 7,2026

4/5

No doors to deal with the front and left side are Accesible .no pandemic precautions , no WiFi , no sit down or table service, no high chairs . No bathrooms A straight olde fashioned ice cream stand, your car is where the magic happens ( floor to product interface ) . The only thing sugar free on the menu is snow cones ( hoping they develope some diabetic friendly ice cream options ) they use penn state creamery ice creams . I had the cherry and rainbow snow cone . Service was quick and friendly . It’s a good location that area needed a drop in quick treat option .picnic tables have now been added to front and rear to sit at

Eric S

Mar 7,2026

4/5

Friendly service, good ice cream, reasonably priced! With very few ice cream options in that area, they are a great addition!

Daniel Gennaro

Mar 7,2026

5/5

Always a fan of a new business and supporting an ice cream shop which creates community! Tasty Penn state ice cream, fair prices at $3 for small and $5 for regular hard ice cream. As a suggestion? Perhaps y’all can redo the parking lines to make the area under the overhang a spot for picnic tables, so remove two parking spots and add back the parking area that has lines for no parking. That way of it rains there’s cover. Plus can add some type of patio string lighting for ambiance. Lastly, a nice mural on the side of building would be nice if you can find a local artist. Perhaps signifying Erie diversity “many flavors, one smile!” Or something like that… thx again for bringing another ice cream place to Erie. Hope it continues to grow

Scott Hess

Mar 7,2026

5/5

Fantastic new ice cream spot just outside Harborcreek in Westerville on Buffalo Road. They have Penn State Creamery and Perry’s Ice cream. Fantastic customer service, super friendly and they let us sample some of their flavors. Highly recommend checking them out!

Sarah Lamary

Mar 7,2026

4/5

Featuring Perry's Ice Cream and Penn State Creamery ice cream!

varundeep merugu

Mar 7,2026

5/5

Oh, I must say, this ice cream, very good na! Perfect for summer, very cooling and tasty also. And, aah, cheap hai na, so I can enjoy anytime, no tension. I really loved it, must try everyone!

Smiley's Ice Cream - in Erie, Pennsylvania, USA

Overview

What Customers Say

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

More in Erie, Pennsylvania, USA